fbpx

Cibelli’s NY Pizza Menu

Enjoy Cibelli’s delicious food and pizza made from gourmet, hand-tossed dough. We’ve got something for everyone in the family. Browse the menu or click a button below to filter the menu.

Pizza (Sizes: Small, Medium, Large, GIANT)

10"
Small
(personal)
14"
Medium
(feeds 2-3)
18"
Large
(feeds 3-4)
24"
GIANT
(feeds 6-8)

Gourmet California

("on white" with chicken, artichoke, sun-dried tomato, pesto)
16.95
24.95
32.95
41.95

Everything Greek

(kalamata olives, sun-dried tomatoes, artichokes, feta)
15.95
20.95
29.95
37.95

BBQ Chicken

(chicken smothered in bbq sauce and covered in mozzarella)
16.95
21.95
29.95
38.95

Margarita

(fresh basil, tomato, mozzarella)
14.95
19.95
27.95
35.95

Meat Lover

(pepperoni, sausage, bacon)
14.95
19.95
27.95
35.95

Veggie

(onions, tomatoes, bell peppers, mushrooms, black olives)
14.95
19.95
27.95
36.95

Combo

(pepperoni, sausage, onions, bell peppers, mushrooms, black olives)
15.95
20.95
29.95
37.95

Hawaiian

(canadian bacon and pineapple)
13.95
17.95
24.95
31.95

Pepperoni

(pepperoni, mozzarella)
12.95
16.95
23.95
29.95

Stuffed Crust

(garlic butter glazed, sprinkled with love, stuffed with mozzarella)
13.95
18.95
26.95
32.95

White Pie

(olive oil, garlic sauce, mozzarella, ricotta, shredded parmesan)
13.95
19.95
25.95
31.95

Cheese Pie

(red sauce, mozzarella)
11.95
15.95
22.95
27.95

Build Your Own Pizza

We’ll make it your way! Choose from our
selection below and Build Your Own Pizza!
(Total price equals Size/Sauce/Crust price + toppings.)

Step #1 Select size and sauce

10"
Small
(personal)
14"
Medium
(feeds 2-3)
18"
Large
(feeds 3-4)
24"
GIANT
(feeds 6-8)
Red Sauce
11.95
15.95
22.95
27.95
White Sauce
13.95
19.95
25.95
31.95

Step #2 Select crust

Now select the type of crust you would like.
(Regular Crusts come standard free of charge.)

10"
Small
(personal)
14"
Medium
(feeds 2-3)
18"
Large
(feeds 3-4)
24"
GIANT
(feeds 6-8)
Regular Crust
no charge
no charge
no charge
no charge
Garlic Butter Love Crust
0.50
0.75
1.00
1.25
Stuffed Crust
(comes with garlic butter love)
2.00
4.00
4.00
5.00

Step #3 Select toppings

Last, create your own pizza by adding as many
Full Toppings or Half Toppings as you would like.
(Mozzarella Cheese comes standard on all pizzas.)

10"
Small
(personal)
14"
Medium
(feeds 2-3)
18"
Large
(feeds 3-4)
24"
GIANT
(feeds 6-8)
Full Toppings
1.70
2.00
2.50
3.50
Half Toppings
X
1.00
1.25
1.75
Meats
Anchovies
Chicken
Salami
Canadian Bacon
Italian Sausage
Pepperoni
(Reg) Veggies
Pepperoncini
Pineapple
Red Onion
White Onion
Bell Pepper
Mushroom
Tomato
Black Olive
(Gourmet) Veggies
Fresh Basil
Kalamata Olives
Roasted Garlic
Sun-dried Tomatoes
Jalapeño
Pesto
Spinach
Artichoke
Cheese Toppings
Feta
Shredded Parmesan
Mozzarella (extra)

Salad (Sizes: Single, Large, Family)

Single
(feeds 1)
Large
(feeds 2)
Family
(feeds 6+)

Cobb

(ham, chicken, bacon, tomato, cucumber, mozzarella)
9.95
12.95
22.95

Manhattan

(romaine, spinach, candied pecans, feta, pineapple, craisins)
9.95
12.95
22.95

Greek

(tomato, artichokes, kalamata olives, sun-dried tomatoes, pepperoncini, feta)
9.95
12.95
22.95

Garden

(black olives, red onion, pepperoncini, tomato, shredded parmesan)
9.95
12.95
22.95

Dinner

(tomato, black olives, cucumber, mozzarella)
9.95
12.95
22.95

Antipasto

(assorted meats, vegetables, peppers, and cheeses)
9.95
12.95
22.95

Caesar

(croutons, shredded parmesan, caesar dressing)
9.95
12.95
22.95

Build Your Own Salad

We’ll make it your way! Choose from our selection below and Build Your Own Salad!

Step #1 Select size

Start with selecting the Size of salad you would like.
Prices listed with up to four toppings added to salad.

* .55¢ for each selection of additional toppings on Single Custom Salads.

Single
(feeds 1)

9.95
Large
(feeds 2)

12.95
Family
(feeds 6+)

22.95

Step #2 Select dressing

Now select the type of dressing you would like.

Number of dressings served with salads:
Single Salad (1)
Large Salad (2)
Family Salad (4)

Extra dressings .55 

Standard
Balsamic Vinaigrette
Blue Cheese
Caesar
Ranch
Italian
Specialty
Caribbean Mango
Sun-dried Tomato
Honey Raspberry
Poppy Seed
Greek Feta

Step #3 Select toppings

Last, create your own salad by adding as many toppings as you would like.

(Up to four salad toppings come without charge)

Single
(feeds 1)
Large
(feeds 2)
Family
(feeds 6+)

Additional Toppings

0.45
1.00
1.50
Meats
Chicken
Salami
Canadian Bacon
Pepperoni
(Reg) Veggies
Cucumber
Pepperoncini
Pineapple
Red Onion
White Onion
Bell Pepper
Mushroom
Tomato
Black Olive
(Gourmet) Veggies
Kalamata Olives
Sun-dried Tomatoes
Jalapeño
Spinach
Artichoke
Cheese Toppings
Feta
Shredded Parmesan
Mozzarella (extra)

Specialty


Price

Gluten Free Crust

Enjoy the light and crispy texture of our new Gluten Free Crust!  (Only comes in the 10" Personal size.)
12.95

Cheese Sticks

These are awesome!
Small 9.95 / Large 12.95

Bread Sticks

Small 8.95 / Large 11.95

Pizzones

Similar to a calzone but stuffed with cheese, sauce, and your choice of any three toppings.
13.95 (Maximum of 3 toppings)

Combo


Price

Slice, Salad, & Soda

Your choice of any single salad and a slice with up to three toppings along with an ice cold soda.
15.95

Dessert


Price

Ice Cream

(Coming Soon)  Assorted flavors, cups, and cones.
Varies

Pizza Dough

10"
14"
18"
24"

Pizza Dough

Our authentic gourmet pizza dough.
4.00
5.00
6.00
8.00